New Essays;
or,
Observations Divine and Moral
By John Robinson

CHAPTER XLIII
OF SUSPICION

Suspicion, as it is commonly taken is, as it were, a looking under a hidden thing, with an inclination to judge it evil and amiss.  It sets the person suspected in a kind of middle state, but something bended the worse way, and neither quit because he is suspected; nor condemned, because he is but suspected.
He that should deal by all persons and things, as Caesar did by his wife, whom he put away, because she was suspected of uncleanness [Suetonius], though solemnly cleared in judgment; should leave himself neither friend, nor wit, nor honesty neither: for all these, and whatsoever else he hath that good is, are subject to unjust suspicion, by others.  Suspicion indeed, how unjust soever is a blemish, and so may justly occasion refusal, where there is free liberty, but not rejection in way of punishment; this is to right a former wrong, by a second greater.
Some suspect all men, and some none: both are in fault; the former in the most sinful fault, the latter in the most honest, but more dangerous to themselves.  And yet even for that, there want not, who by causeless suspicion teach their servants, friends, yea wives, and children also to deceive them [Seneca].  For many respecting more their credit with men, than a good conscience before God, by being suspected, though causelessly, grow desperate; yea think themselves half privileged to deceive them that suspect them; seeing that by so doing, they but become that, which they are deemed to be before.  It is best therefore, first not to suspect without good cause; next, not to betray our suspicion, except we have great hope to overawe thereby the suspected person.
There are many, unreasonably though not altogether unoccasioned, transported from the one of the extremes formerly mentioned to the other: who being at first credulous, and light of belief, and thereby oft deceived, at length come to trust none; but would burn, as they say, their shirt, if they thought it knew their secrets: and therefore set it down for a rule, to have all men in jealousy.  Such overwise men are like the fool, that because the sieve deceived him, and let his drink run out, would not trust his dish with it afterwards.  Howsoever things fall out, it is best to keep our bias always on the right side; and to incline still to a better, rather than to a worse opinion of men, than they deserve.  For though it be best of all, to judge of others just as they are: yet seeing, that is always hard and sometimes impossible, we shall less offend God in judging of men too well, though sometimes to our own damage, than too ill, with certain injury to them, and sin in ourselves, in the violation of the law of charity, which “is not suspicious.”  1 Cor. xiii.5.
The general cause of suspicion is the want of this true love, whose property is to believe all things, and to hope all things, which with reason, can be believed, or hoped for; and so men are in danger to presume of, and promise to themselves more good of their wives and children and friends, whom they entirely love, than there is cause, rather than otherwise.  Notwithstanding, a very inordinate, and doting affection also breeds causeless jealousy.  Another general cause of suspicion is the knowledge and consciousness which persons have of their own inability, and weakness any way.  Of beasts and birds, hares and cover, and such impotent, and unarmed creatures; and of men and women; the childish, weak, silly and decrepit are most given to suspicion, as being most subject to be circumvented and oppressed.  So it hath been observed, how the Scythians, and other barbarous nations have labored to supply their defects of wisdom for prevention of hurt from enemies, by excess of suspicion [Bodinus].  It is true, that this disease sometimes befalls very wise men; but this arises from another and worse cause, to wit, an evil conscience.  Men muse as they use, and suspect others by themselves; as is common with all lewd persons.  He that is good himself, does not easily suspect another to be evil: nor the evil, that another is good [Chrysostom].  Besides, an evil conscience accusing men and women, that they in truth deserve not love, nor respect, nor credit, easily persuades them, that they are not loved, nor respected, nor credited by others.  Lastly, it is often a punishment from God, that as a man in debt, suspects that every bush which he sees, is sergeant to arrest him; so they which are without true grace, and assurance of the pardon of their sins from him, should be suspicious, that every one would deceive, or hurt them otherwise.  It was God’s curse upon Cain, when he had killed his brother Abel, to suspect and fear that every one that he met with, would kill him.  Gen. Iv.8.  Notwithstanding all these things; sometimes God sends a spirit of jealousy upon interested persons, Numb. V.12, &c, for the discovery of evils in others formerly hidden; which out of probably suspicion come to be searched into, and by searching are found out.  And always we must strive for that discretion and wisdom, as not to take our marks amiss, by censuring any rashly, as Eli did Hannah for drunkenness, because her lips went, and her voice was not heard: nor yet to be so fondly charitable, as not to see the spots of men’s leprosy breaking out in their foreheads.
 We are not only by innocency to prevent just blame; but withal, by Christian care, and wisdom, to provide that we hurt not our good name by coming under colorable suspicion of evil.  We provide things honest before God by preserving innocency; but before men, by giving no probably cause of their suspecting us.  And so doing, if yet God by his providence, so ordered, that we come under it; we must bear it patiently, as a burden laid upon us by him, either to prove us; as it was not the least trial upon Job, to be suspected by his friends and others of hypocrisy: or, it may be, to warn us to take heed of some sin, of which we are in danger, though not guilty of: it may be, for our present peace and safety, as it happened to David, by being suspected of the lords of the Philistines; or, it may be, for their just punishment, by whom we are unjustly suspected; as in the same David’s case, in being suspected by king Saul of affecting the kingdom, to his own great harm in wanting him, and the worthies with him in the battle with the Philistines.

www.pilgrimhall.org

Updated 18 May, 2005